For Matteo di Mino di Pagliaio. New considerations on the Sienese goldsmith's art in the second half of the Trecento

Elisabetta Cioni
The text focuses on various aspects of the goldsmith's art in Siena in the second half of the Trecento, as well as other issues relating to the study of this argument. The loss of an enormous patrimony is underlined. It draws, therefore, in the first place, on a paper presented by the author at the Parma conference Medioevo: arte e storia in 2007, published in 2008, in which the Sienese Cross with champlevé enamels then in the Cleveland Museum of Art – which in 2009 fortunately returned to its place of origin, the church of Santi Pietro e Andrea in Trequanda (Siena) – was analysed in particular. The work was associated with the activity of Bartolomeo di Tommè known as 'Pizzino', and Mariano d'Agnolo Romanelli, without excluding references to Matteo d'Ambrogio known as 'Sapa'. The aim here is to demonstrate that one of the works taken into consideration at the Parma conference – the Reliquary-Cross of the Museo Nazionale del Bargello (inv. OR 57), to be linked with the Trequanda Cross – can be related to the only known artifact signed by the Sienese goldsmith Matteo di Mino di Pagliaio, documented from 1369 to 1380, to whom the present paper is dedicated in particular. This is the Chalice now at the Kunstgewerbemuseum in Berlin (inv. K 4266), whose original place of destination is unknown and is badly damaged, a fact that has inevitably and understandably contributed to the scarce consideration of the work by art scholars. The translucent enamels decorating it, however deteriorated, are in fact stylistically very similar to those, carried out with the same technique, of the Reliquary-Cross of the Bargello. We therefore have a large nucleus of small low-relief plaque enamels to which – despite being aware of the limits imposed by the peculiar nature of this kind of artifact – we may link the figure of a historically documented goldsmith belonging to a family in which goldworking was practised. This means being able to include – on the basis of surviving figurative evidence (and not just documentary evidence, which is fairly scanty) – the activity of Matteo di Mino di Pagliaio in that context which sees involved, with working roles that are difficult if not impossible to define and circumscribe, the above-mentioned goldsmiths, masters all working on the execution of sculptures for the Cappella di Piazza del Campo. In the second part of the paper the Reliquary of the True Cross from the church of San Giovanni Battista at Querceto (Montecatini Val di Cecina) is analysed. This is a small cuspidated Gothic tabernacle with side panels, in silver gilt, made in Siena, we would suggest, in the late 1350s or during the 1360s.

Index

Alessandro Bagnoli Mariano d'Agnolo Romanelli and the Reliquary of Pope Mark: the return of enamelling 'a figure risparmiate' in the late Trecento
read abstract » pag. 3-11
Elisabetta Cioni For Matteo di Mino di Pagliaio. New considerations on the Sienese goldsmith's art in the second half of the Trecento
read abstract » pag. 12-46
Maria Falcone On the Tomb monument of Margaret of Brabant, the Tomb of Doge Tommaso Campofregoso and other Ligurian works of the Quattrocento
read abstract » pag. 47-89
Gianluca Amato The 'Dead Christ' by Francesco di Giorgio at Santa Maria dei Servi in Siena
read abstract » pag. 90-141
Annamaria Petrioli Tofani For a catalogue of drawings by Agostino Melissi at the Uffizi
read abstract » pag. 142-173
Gianmarco Russo Longhi, reader of Vasari
read abstract » pag. 174-199
Anna Santucci A 'Pseudo-Vitellius' in the Uffizi Gallery (and other 'Pseudo-Vitellius' busts in Florence between the 16th and the 19th century)
read abstract » pp. 200-217
Jörg Deterling An 'Apollo' relief from the Giustiniani collection
read abstract » pag. 218-220
Anna Anguissola Observations on the catalogue of the Dresden sculptures: the case of the “four ancient small young fauns”
read abstract » pag. 221-225
Valentina Balzarotti Pellegrino Tibaldi in the church of Sant'Andrea in Via Flaminia
read abstract » pag. 226-232
Giovanni Renzi Two works by Camillo Procaccini in Tuscany and an episode in the history of collectionism
read abstract » pag. 233-251
Luca Fiorentino Cornelis de Bie and Gian Lorenzo Bernini: observations regarding the critical fortune of Bernini in the Seicento
read abstract » pag. 252-261
Giovanni Agosti e Jacopo Stoppa Controversy and peace on the “Grechetto”
read abstract » pag. 262-273
Giovanni Agosti For Enzo Mengaldo, between two languages
read abstract » pag. 274-282