“Chi perde vince” ("He who loses wins"): a 'Salvatore' by Gian Lorenzo and Pietro Bernini (circa 1617-19)

The paper presents a marble bust depicting a Salvator mundi offered at a Sotheby's London auction of 2010 with a “Circle of Pietro Bernini” attribution and currently in a private collection in New York. We propose that the sculpture (datable by style to circa 1617-19), as yet unpublished in the scholarly literature, was undoubtedly executed by Pietro Bernini but that the invention, composition, and probably the models be recognized as the work of the young but already affirmed Gian Lorenzo. The bust displays a new focus, an unknown solidity, and a palpable interior life that prompted presentation of Christ as the story of a character, almost a biography, or at least as an individual psychology, and therefore as a portrait, not an object or a whimsical still life in marble. The Christ is planned and 'built' like a portrait though Pietro probably had never before sculpted a portrait (at least we know of none), and had always remained diligently within the bounds of established genres. This 'portrait of Christ' tends instead to supersede those boundaries taking advantage of the great lesson of the contemporary painting of Annibale Carracci and Caravaggio. In the complex variety of collaborations between father and son in the second decade of the Seicento, such an inversion of the natural roles of father-master and son-pupil is very rare; it is precisely for this reason that the re-emergence of the bust is particularly significant. No less interesting is the subject of the work: a bust of Christ rooted in the purest Florentine tradition. The marble constitutes a fundamental link in the transmission from father to son of an iconographic model that Gian Lorenzo would cultivate until the end in the grand 'Salvator mundi ' from his last years, the original of which we recognize in the example at Norfolk, assigning the version at San Sebastiano fuori le Mura at Rome instead to Giuseppe Mazzuoli.

Index

Roberto Bartalini Ambrogio Lorenzetti a Montesiepi. Sulla committenza e la cronologia degli affreschi della cappella di San Galgano
read abstract » pag. 2-18
Rosanna De Gennaro, Paolo Giannattasio Messina in the travel diary and drawings of Willem Schellinks
read abstract » pag. 19-49
Gail A. Solberg Taddeo di Bartolo e Rinaldo Brancaccio a Roma: Santa Maria in Trastevere e Santa Maria Maggiore
read abstract » pag. 50-73
Alessandro Angelini Una 'Sant'Agnese di Montepulciano' di Domenico Beccafumi. Per una revisione dell'attività giovanile del pittore
read abstract » pag. 74-93
Andrea Giorgi "Domenicho dipentore sta in chasa di Lorenso Bechafumi". Di alcuni documenti poliziani intorno al culto di Agnese Segni e ai suoi riflessi in ambito artistico (1506-1507)
read abstract » pag. 94-103
Claudio Gulli Girolamo del Pacchia's cataletto for the Confraternity of San Bernardino in Siena
read abstract » pag. 104-121
Giovanni Agosti A short note about Titian
read abstract » pag. 122-131
Patrizia Tosini Boncompagni and Guastavillani patronage in the Capuchin church at Frascati: an addition for Niccolò Trometta and a hypothesis about the 'Painter of Filippo Guastavillani'
read abstract » pag. 132-141
Fausto Nicolai Cesare Nebbia and the decoration of the Florenzi chapel in San Silvestro al Quirinale. The contract of 1579 and Nebbiaʼs working relationship with Girolamo Muziano
read abstract » pag. 142-151
A Neapolitan altarpiece by Alessandro Casolani: "Sant'Alfonso quando riceve l'habito sacerdotale dalla Madonna"
read abstract » pag. 152-161
Marco Tanzi Tanzio da Varallo: a Neapolitan portrait
read abstract » pag. 162-176
Tomaso Montanari “Chi perde vince” ("He who loses wins"): a 'Salvatore' by Gian Lorenzo and Pietro Bernini (circa 1617-19)
read abstract » pag. 176-191
Jacopo Stoppa Ferdinando Porta's curriculum in Marcello Oretti's papers
read abstract » pag. 192-204